The Montauket has been around since the late and has remained a classic time honored Montauk tradition ever since. Family owned since 1959, The Montauket; (known by locals) is a place where all kinds gather to watch the sun set over Gardiner's Island. From lobster rolls to fresh locally caught seafood – from local beers to specialty drinks, the Montauket is a casual laid back spot to enjoy an afternoon and take in the sunset with live music.